Not Everyone Says I Love You
By Matthew Coslett
On March 14, 2016
During the Meiji Restoration, Japanese linguists were presented with one of their biggest linguistic challenges: how to translate a new word ‘love’ into Japanese. While this may sound like a simple word-to-word translation, at that time Japanese culture simply lacked the idea of romantic love as it was known in the West.
Instead love in Japan was, like most Japanese cultural words, linked with complex interplays between people. After much discussion, the word
These days, 愛 is definitely out of fashion. When men were polled by the dating site Sugoren about how they expressed their love, most considered that 愛 was too strong for anything but the most intense moments. Instead the resounding winners were the softer words such as
Of course, the reasons given for this preference say a lot about the Japanese people who were questioned. In follow-up questions, many reported that 好き felt more natural; they felt too shy to say 愛する; or, bizarrely, felt that using a strong word like 愛 cost them some of their natural macho appeal!
While this may make readers concerned that the Japanese are an unromantic lot, it is worth bearing in mind that the English translations of words are at best an approximate translation of the nuances of the Japanese language. Even though ‘I like you’ is possibly the worst thing a person could hear in English, 好きだよ said with passion can be full of emotion and love. Even the queen of lovey-dovey J. pop ballads Mei ‘May J’ Hashimoto felt that ‘
Since the Meiji,
However, it is not quite as simple as a direct translation from ‘love’ to 恋. The writer Itou Susumu in his book ‘Japanese Love’ noted that 恋 was likely evolved from the concepts of こ (alone) and ひ (sadness). In other words the word describes the yearning for someone to break the sorrow of living alone: very different to the concept of a romantic love.
This idea is expanded beautifully by the anthropologist Professor Ryang in her book Love in Modern Japan. ‘(恋 resides) in the attraction of the other, not in oneself…’ She writes, ‘Koi is not controlled by one’s willpower – it is inevitable, a product of fate, a power that goes beyond human capacity.’
Wow! Try telling that to your girlfriend this White Day, guys!
When two kanji both describe part of a concept, it is only a matter of time before both were put together to make the word
These days of course, the closest equivalent to the English word ‘love’ is the loanword ラブ and its cute version ラブラブ. This word is often found in modern words that describe concepts that came into Japan after the Meiji as trade with other countries increased such as ラブアフェア (A love affair), ラブレター (A love letter) and ラブコール (A love call).
Ultimately, all of these different words highlight a dangerous trap that many people can fall into: assuming that love is expressed and even felt in the same way in cultures with very different histories. Love is just one of these concepts that is so uniquely linked to our own perceptions that its interpretation can vary greatly. Ultimately, the important point is not how your partner chooses to express their love in this romantic season, but the feelings behind it.
Happy White Day everyone!